About Us

We have been in business as a sole proprietorship since 1986.  Since our inception and years of growing out business, we have both left our "paid employement" in basic research and the health care industry.  We specialize in fine jewelry sales and repair, diamonds, colored gems, and custom jewelry. Essentially all work is done on the premises.  We have a variety of jewelry unique to our shop, our fine colored gemstones are normally not seen in retail chain stores. Diamond and non-traditional engagement rings at significant savings!  We also handle estate and refurbished jewelry. We strive to consistently provide quality, friendly service with integrity and value.  


Gemistry Jewelry is the local authority on all things jewelry, gold, silver, and gemstones. We carry and have access to a wide variety of jewelry, diamonds and gems.  Taking your ideas, we are determined to find or make the right piece for you.


We strive to offer expert advise, service of unsurpassed integrity and value.  You will talk to the person doing your work or one of the owners of the business.  We strive to exceed your expectations...  experience the Gemistry difference!

Meet the "Mom & Pop" owners:

Andy & Sue McWilliams:  The crazy guy on the left does the work.  The crazy gal on the right puts up with the guy on the left when he does the work!



Gemistry Jewelry

2751 Horseshoe Pike

Palmyra, PA 17078


Phone: (717) 838-8870


Or fill out our contact form.

$3 Watch Batteries-Installed!       Tax Included


Tue thru Fri 9am - 4pm

Sat     9am - Noon

Sun & Mon   closed

Print Print | Sitemap
© Gemistry Jewelry