At Gemistry we have a large selection of fine jewelry, diamonds & colored gems for sale.  We offer fine jewelry sales and expert repair.  We are licensed jewelry and precious metal buyers.  Bring us you unwanted or damaged jewelry for trade or cash.  Our selection of  pre-owned jewelry is constantly changing....  stop by often to see what's new.  Our store also has a selection of minerals, fossils and natural history items.   We have something for everyone!


Follow us Facebook - We list new items continually.  Follow what is currently happening at the store!

Ring sizings start at only $35!

24-48 hour usual turn-around!!

All repairs done on the premises!!!

Birthstone for February - Amethyst

While most of our colored gemstones and diamonds come from exotic destinations all over the world.  The finished jewelry, precious metals, mountings and findings used in our jewelry are made in the USA.  All repair work is done in house.

Gemistry Jewelry

2751 Horseshoe Pike

Palmyra, PA 17078


Phone: (717) 838-8870


Or fill out our contact form.

$3 Watch Batteries-Installed!       Tax Included


Tue thru Fri 9am - 4pm

Sat     9am - Noon

Sun & Mon   closed

Always Buying Gold & Silver

We are happy to buy your unwanted jewelry, coins, and precious metal and offer reasonable payouts for your items.

Print Print | Sitemap
© Gemistry Jewelry